Do I need to perfect the langauges I currently have before moving onto the next?
Our take
In a world where language is both a bridge and a barrier, the question posed by a 19-year-old med student grappling with their multilingual aspirations resonates deeply. The dilemma of whether to perfect existing languages before diving into new ones is not just a personal struggle; it reflects a broader narrative about the nature of learning, growth, and the ever-evolving journey of self-discovery. This conversation echoes sentiments found in discussions such as Feedback on my language learning plan and Should I give up and learn a different language instead?, showing that the anxiety surrounding language acquisition is a common thread among learners.
The crux of the issue lies in the perception of language proficiency. The original poster feels constrained by the notion of perfection, equating polyglottery with flawless communication. Yet, language is inherently about connection, expression, and, dare I say, the delightful messiness of communication. It's a living, breathing entity that evolves alongside us. The fear of not being "good enough" in a language can stifle creativity and discourage exploration. It's important to recognize that the journey of learning is often nonlinear, filled with detours that can enrich one's understanding of not just the languages themselves but the cultures they represent. Why not embrace the imperfection and allow it to coexist with the desire to learn more?
Moreover, the juxtaposition of busy schedules with the desire to learn is a narrative familiar to many. The notion that progress must be constant and linear is a societal construct that often leads to feelings of inadequacy. The poster mentions that their current approach involves listening to podcasts and solitary practice. While these methods have merit, they may inadvertently foster a sense of isolation in the learning process. Engaging with others—whether through conversation or language exchange—can illuminate new pathways and spark motivation. It’s a reminder that language learning is not a solitary endeavor; it thrives in community and connection.
As we ponder the desire to learn Mandarin Chinese while feeling guilty about not mastering French and Turkish, we’re reminded of the beauty of curiosity. Learning should be fueled by passion rather than guilt. The act of diving into a new language can invigorate existing knowledge, providing fresh perspectives and sparking newfound enthusiasm. Embracing the idea that one can learn multiple languages concurrently can be liberating. It reflects a mindset that values exploration and lifelong learning over rigid standards of achievement.
Ultimately, the journey of language learning is as much about the destination as it is about the experiences along the way. It’s about finding joy in the slippery, narrow moments—the “razor clam” insights that surface when we least expect them. As our original poster contemplates their next steps, they might ask themselves: What if the pursuit of languages is not merely about perfection, but about the connections made, the thoughts expressed, and the horizons expanded? Might they dare to explore not just the languages but also the philosophies that accompany them, as they venture into the delightful chaos of multilingualism? The journey is just beginning, and the possibilities are as vast as the languages themselves.
I am 19, I'm in my first year of med school, my native language is arabic and I also place myself around B2 in french and B1 in turkish.
I am never satisfied with my level in either of those langauges, I'm interested in philosophy but I cant comfortably read books in french, even short ones like 'Le petit prince' require a little more effort than reading anything in english.
In turkish it's even worse, words always escape me and I can't express myself in a manner that feels "mine" if that makes sense, I am confined to the few words that I have.
Tbh, I probably don't make much progress in either langauge because I mainly listen to podcasts and speak to myself, mainly because I've been busy for the past 2 years.
But now I have more free time on my hand, I wanted to learn german but I decided not to since I'll have to learn it eventually before I finish med school, and so I've been thinking about learning mandarin chinese. But I feel so guilty because I still have 2 langauges that I did not yet perfect. And it's supporting the idea that I'm impulsive and that I can't follow through with the goals I intend to achieve.
Should I not listen to these thoughts and just do what I feel like doing? Or should I introduce more discipline to my langauge learning journey by reaching a high level in these languages?
I guess my goal is to be able to read almost everything I come across in both languages and to communicate effortlessly in the most intentional way. But I'm starting to lose hope on being able to do so, as my progress feels like it's slowing down exponentially.
I don't view myself as a polyglot, in my mind a polyglot is someone who has perfect communication in multiple languages (not just 2 in my case)
What do you guys think I should do?
[link] [comments]
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience
Related Articles
- Feedback on my language learning planHello everyone! I'm about to embark on a language learning journey but I wanted some perspective and feedback from people more advanced in their journey than I am. I'm portuguese and I can also speak english at somewhere near native and I understand spanish pretty much perfectly (though I'm not confident in speaking it). My language knowledge so far as been automatic and a result of that child like brute forcing of learning, so I don't have much experience with more formal language learning. I did give it a try with japanese but I was too young and basically only did Duolingo + Anki which ended up being very annoying and I eventually just gave up. My plan right now is to try to learn french as sort of a "tutorial" and as a way to workshop a language learning process that is fun and engaging for me before moving on to mandarin which is my ultimate goal. Both have pretty complex reasons as to why I want to learn them, but I wanted to reflect on why my previous japanese journey didn't work and this is where a different, more mature perspective is very valuable. I did have a lot of motivation, but I felt like it got progressively harder and very repetitive, and I stopped feeling like I was making progress. Even when I dedicated a lot of time, it just felt like I was practicing the same stuff and like I was not really consolidating the new vocab. It made me feel dumb and undisciplined, but as I've come to understand, this usually just means a flawed process, and not a display of my shortcomings (especially knowing how much people in this space flame duolingo lol). My plan is to use a more diverse set of tools, with different aspects to it (listening, conversing, less gamey type of apps) to try to have a more dynamic learning experience, hoping that these different aspects will synergize, but I'm very afraid of plateaus and I wanted to know what did you guys usually do when you found yourselves in one as it is probably the most challenging part of language learning. This and any another advice/perspective would be appreciated :), thank you for your time reading my post submitted by /u/KantGettEnuff [link] [comments]
- Should I give up and learn a different language instead?3 years ago I started learning Japanese because I have been exposed to Japanese media since I was little so it made sense for me to learn it as my 3rd language but I stopped after a year because I was a college student at the time who had a lot of studying to do and after graduation I also had to spend months focusing on a very important exam that I need to take in order to get into medical school. A couple of months have passed and all of that’s been finally done so I went to gauge my Japanese proficiency, only to find out that I feel like I lost a lot of what I knew back then. Although beginner level, I was actually able to have short conversations with Japanese natives in hellotalk and irl, and even made friends there. Right now I am currently debating whether I should relearn as this language is actually something I’m very interested to learn but I worry that when med school starts I would have a hard time keeping it up. I enjoy language learning and if I do end up pausing Japanese for now, I would also love to learn French as I feel it would be relatively easier than Japanese. What do you guys think? submitted by /u/Mindless_Finding3617 [link] [comments]
- If you were giving yourself until the end of the year to keep studying a language, what would be your approach?For context, I've been learning Arabic for a long time, MSA and Jordanian/Levantine in general. I studied MSA for 4 years in college, but after graduating I set it aside for a couple years with everything I had going on. I started reviewing MSA and began to learn Jordanian in preparation for a vacation to Jordan. Afterwards, I kept with it because my Jordanian level was still fairly low and I was enjoying the process. At the beginning of this year, however, I was thinking about goals (as many people do at that time of year). I realized I no longer had a clear goal or vision for learning Arabic. I don't live near Arabic-speaking communities, I don't use it at work, and besides an Internet friend, I don't text (let alone speak) the language with others much at all. I have visited two Arabic-speaking countries in the last few years, but it's extremely unlikely I will visit another anytime soon. So after thinking through that, I decided I would give one more year with Arabic as my main language of focus. Whatever my level is on December 31st, I'll be content. I'm hoping to reach a point where I can understand a strong majority of what I hear in Youtube videos and what I read in articles. But there are other languages I'll want to study (and other hobbies in general) and I don't currently have the time I did a few years ago. So, if you were giving yourself a deadline where focused, intensive study of a language will cease, how would you approach it? What would you focus on? I've been meeting every week or two with a tutor - how would you maximize these sessions? Would you create a detailed plan for the remaining months, or just make sure you're doing something active with the language every day for 30+ minutes? I am curious to hear any ideas and thoughts. I won't let Arabic fade until I've forgotten almost everything - I'll still keep the language in maintenance mode (nothing horrifies me more than letting hundreds or thousands of hours go to waste and eventually forgetting everything I've learned). But I'll more or less stop actively learning new things. submitted by /u/Daghatar [link] [comments]